I’m Nathan Cate. I defend felony cases in Davidson, Williamson, Sumner, Rutherford, Wilson, Cheatham, and Robertson counties — and the preliminary hearing is the first real fight in almost every one of them. Most clients show up to it not knowing what it is. Most defendants who come in unrepresented waive it. And waiving it, in most cases, is a mistake.
A preliminary hearing is a free deposition of the State’s lead witness, a free shot at dismissal, and the only chance the defense gets to lock in the State’s theory under oath before the case goes to grand jury. Here’s what actually happens, what your lawyer should be doing, and why it matters.
What a Preliminary Hearing Is
In Tennessee, when a person is arrested on a felony charge, they’re brought before a General Sessions Court judge. The case starts in General Sessions even though felonies have to be tried in Criminal Court — General Sessions handles the front end through the preliminary hearing. The preliminary hearing is the procedural gate the case has to pass through before it can be presented to a grand jury and indicted.
The governing rule is Tenn. R. Crim. P. 5.1. The judge’s job at the preliminary hearing is to decide one question: is there probable cause to believe a felony was committed and that the defendant committed it?
That is a low bar. Lower than the trial standard of beyond a reasonable doubt. Lower than the preponderance standard used in civil cases. Probable cause means the State has shown enough — through testimony and exhibits — that a reasonable person would have grounds to suspect the defendant committed the crime.
If the judge finds probable cause, the case is bound over to the grand jury. If the judge does not find probable cause, the case is dismissed at General Sessions. The State can re-indict — meaning it can take the case directly to grand jury despite the dismissal — but the dismissal is still meaningful, and many cases that are dismissed at preliminary hearing don’t come back.
When the Hearing Happens
Tennessee Rule of Criminal Procedure 5(d) sets the timing. A defendant in custody is generally entitled to a preliminary hearing within 10 days of arrest. A defendant out on bond is entitled to a hearing within 30 days. Continuances happen, but the right to the hearing is structural — the State has the burden to bring its witnesses and put on its case within the timeline, and failure to do so can result in dismissal.
For defendants who can’t make bond, the preliminary hearing is often the first real opportunity to attack the case while sitting in jail. A successful preliminary hearing is also the fastest path home.
What Actually Happens in the Courtroom
The preliminary hearing is held in front of a General Sessions judge — no jury. The State calls witnesses (usually the affiant officer who signed the arrest warrant, sometimes the alleged victim, sometimes both). The State puts on its evidence. The defense cross-examines. The defense can call its own witnesses, though that is rarely strategic at this stage. Then the judge rules.
The hearing is on the record. Testimony given at preliminary hearing is sworn testimony, transcribed by the court reporter, and usable later in the case under Tennessee Rules of Evidence — including for impeachment at trial.
The Standard of Proof Is Low
Probable cause is not “did the State prove its case.” It’s “did the State show enough that the case should keep going.” Many defendants are surprised when the judge binds the case over despite testimony that seemed thin. That isn’t a sign the lawyer did poor work — that’s the standard. The point of the hearing is rarely to win it outright (though that does happen). The point is to get the State on the record, lock in the theory, and identify the weaknesses for the next phase.
Probable Cause vs. Specific Charges
Even when probable cause exists for some offense, the defense lawyer’s job is to push the judge on which offense. A case charged as aggravated assault might survive on probable cause for simple assault but not for aggravated assault. A case charged as aggravated robbery might survive on probable cause for theft but not for aggravated robbery. The judge has the power to bind over on a lesser-included offense, and that decision can fundamentally change the case before it ever reaches the grand jury.
What Your Defense Lawyer Should Be Doing
This is where the difference between an active preliminary hearing and a perfunctory one shows up. The defense work at preliminary hearing — done right — looks like:
Cross-Examining the Affiant Officer
The affiant officer is the person who signed the arrest warrant. They are usually the State’s first and only witness at preliminary hearing, and they are testifying based on a report they wrote weeks earlier. Cross-examination at preliminary hearing is the only chance to:
- Lock the officer into a specific narrative under oath.
- Identify omissions in the report.
- Force the officer to admit what they don’t know firsthand (most of the report is hearsay from other officers and witnesses).
- Test the officer’s recollection against body camera, dispatch records, and physical evidence the defense lawyer has already pulled.
Done well, the cross becomes a deposition the State did not consent to. Done poorly, it becomes a free preview of the trial cross — and that’s a problem, because it tells the State exactly what to fix before grand jury and trial.
Locking in Witnesses
When the alleged victim or another civilian witness is called at preliminary hearing, their testimony is captured on the record. Inconsistent statements at trial — relative to the preliminary hearing testimony — can be used for impeachment under Tennessee Rule of Evidence 613. Witness statements that seem clean at preliminary hearing often fall apart later when compared against text messages, social media, and other discovery the defense pulls.
Identifying Weaknesses
Probable cause is enough to bind over, but the testimony at preliminary hearing reveals the State’s case as it actually exists in the first 30 days post-arrest — before the State has had time to clean it up. That preview is invaluable for plea negotiations, suppression motions, and trial strategy.
Moving for Dismissal Where Probable Cause Is Genuinely Lacking
Some preliminary hearings are winnable outright. Identification cases where the witness can’t ID the defendant in court. Cases where the officer’s testimony establishes only a misdemeanor. Cases where a key element — intent, possession, identity — is genuinely missing from the State’s proof. These are not the majority of cases, but they exist, and they’re the cases that get dismissed in General Sessions and never come back.
Why Defendants Waive — and Why That’s Usually a Mistake
The most common reasons defendants waive preliminary hearing are:
- Plea negotiations. The State offers a deal that’s only on the table if the defendant doesn’t put on a hearing. This trades a real opportunity for a marginal benefit, and it usually only makes sense in cases the defense has already evaluated as unwinnable.
- The lawyer doesn’t have the file ready. Discovery hasn’t come in. Body camera hasn’t been reviewed. The witness list hasn’t been investigated. Continuances are available — but lawyers who waive instead of continue are leaving the most important pretrial leverage on the table.
- The defendant doesn’t want to “make the State angry.” This is the worst reason. The State is not going to be angrier with you for asking for a hearing. The State will calibrate its plea offer based on the relative strength of its case, and the strength of the State’s case is exactly what the preliminary hearing tests.
A felony case that gets bound over to grand jury without a preliminary hearing has been bound over without ever being challenged. That’s a structural failure of the defense, not a strategic choice.
After the Hearing — What Happens Next
If probable cause is found, the case is bound over and the file is sent to the District Attorney’s Office for grand jury presentment. Indictment usually follows within 30 to 90 days, though it can take longer in complex cases. After indictment, the case moves to Criminal Court, the judge changes, and the next steps are arraignment in Criminal Court, discovery, motion practice, and trial setting.
If probable cause is not found, the case is dismissed in General Sessions. The State retains the right to take the matter directly to grand jury without re-arrest, but in many cases — especially cases dismissed for genuine evidentiary problems — the State does not refile.
For the broader framework on how I approach felony cases at every stage, see Practice Areas and Violent Crimes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a preliminary hearing the same as a trial? No. A preliminary hearing is a probable cause determination — much lower standard than a trial, no jury, no determination of guilt. The trial happens later, in Criminal Court, after grand jury indictment.
Can I be acquitted at the preliminary hearing? You can be dismissed but not acquitted. Acquittal is a trial term. Dismissal at preliminary hearing means the case stops moving forward — but the State can re-indict if it chooses to.
Should I testify at my preliminary hearing? Almost never. Defendants who testify at preliminary hearing give the State a free deposition that locks them into a story they may not want to tell at trial. The strategic decision should always be made with a lawyer.
What if the State doesn’t bring its witness? Tennessee Rule of Criminal Procedure 5.1 requires the State to put on enough evidence to establish probable cause. If the State is not ready and the case has been continued past the deadline without good cause, dismissal can be the appropriate remedy.
How long does the hearing take? Most preliminary hearings run 30 minutes to an hour. Complex cases — multiple defendants, multiple witnesses, technical evidence — can run several hours or be set for a half-day. Either way, the time invested is short relative to the leverage gained.
If my case is bound over, does that mean I’m going to be convicted? No. Bind-over means the case proceeds to grand jury, not that the defendant has been found guilty of anything. The burden of proof at trial is much higher than at preliminary hearing, and many cases bound over at General Sessions are ultimately dismissed, reduced, or won at trial in Criminal Court.
If You’re Facing a Felony Charge in Tennessee, Call
I’m Nathan Cate. I handle preliminary hearings as active fights — not as procedural waypoints. If you’ve been arrested on a felony in Davidson, Williamson, Sumner, Rutherford, Wilson, Cheatham, or Robertson County, call before your first court date. The preliminary hearing window is 10 to 30 days. The work that has to be done before then has to be done quickly.
Call (615) 664-8083 for a free consultation.
N. Cate Law · 222 2nd Avenue North, Suite 220 · Nashville, TN 37201 catelaw.com · Practice Areas · Violent Crimes
This is general legal information about Tennessee law. It is not legal advice for any specific case. If you have a pending case, contact N. Cate Law for case-specific guidance.
#NashvilleCriminalLawyer #TennesseePreliminaryHearing #CriminalProcedure #FelonyDefense